Baevich

AI receptionist for a small firm. When you need one and which to pick

By Andrew BaevichChecked on

A small firm needs an AI receptionist when it misses new enquiries, after hours or while everyone is in meetings, and a single new client is worth far more than the monthly fee. It does not need one if most calls come from existing clients and someone is at the front desk all day. Whatever you pick, it must pass urgent calls, existing clients, requests for advice and anyone who asks for a person straight to a human.

Below we compare six products a small law or accounting firm is likely to look at. Prices are list prices from each vendor's public pricing page, checked on 20 November 2026. Our verdicts are based on the vendor's public pricing and docs, not on a hands-on test of each product.

Six AI receptionists compared

Prices in US dollars, before tax. Checked on 20 November 2026.
Product, links to its pricing pageWho answersCheapest paid plan and billingFree plan or trialPassing a call to a person
Smith.ai AI ReceptionistAI first, with live receptionists as backup$150 a month for 75 calls. Per call, $2.50 for each extra call on ProFree plan with 25 calls a monthTransfers to your numbers, or to a Smith.ai live receptionist for complex calls
RubyLive human receptionists, with optional AI features$250 a month for 50 minutes. Per minute of receptionist timeNot stated on the pricing pageA person answers every call and connects or takes a message
GoodcallAI only$79 a month for 100 unique callers. Per unique caller, 79 cents for each extra caller on StarterFree demo agent, you pay when you connect a numberTransfers to the people you choose, or takes a message
RosieAI only$49 a month for 250 minutes. Per minute7-day free trialTakes messages on the $49 plan. Live and warm transfers start on Scale, $149 a month
DialzaraAI only$29 a month for 60 minutes. Per minute, $0.48 for each extra minute on Lite7-day free trialBlind transfer on every plan. Warm transfer starts on Business Pro, $99 a month
My AI Front DeskAI only$99 a month, or $79 a month billed annually, 200 voice minutes. Per minute, $0.25 for each extra minute7-day free trialCall transfer is one of the actions you set up, with alerts to up to 3 people

Smith.ai also sells plans where people answer first. They start at $300 a month for 30 calls, see the Smith.ai pricing page.

When a small firm needs one

  • You find missed calls from unknown numbers in the evening or at lunch, and some never call back.
  • Partners or senior staff answer the phone themselves between meetings.
  • New clients come from search or ads, so they call several firms and pick the first one that answers.
  • One new client is worth more than a year of the subscription.

When you can skip it

  • Most calls are from existing clients who want their own lawyer or accountant.
  • Someone covers the phone all day, and evening calls are rare.
  • New work arrives mainly by referral email. Then a faster email reply does more than a phone robot.

What it must hand to a human

Write this list down before you set anything up, and test each case with a real call.

  1. Anyone who says it is urgent. A hearing tomorrow, an arrest, a deadline, a tax or court notice with a date on it.
  2. Existing clients asking about their own matter or file. The receptionist confirms who they are and passes them on.
  3. Any request for advice. A receptionist collects facts and books a meeting. It never gives an opinion on a case or a tax position.
  4. Callers who are upset, distressed or confused.
  5. Questions about fees, invoices and payment disputes.
  6. Anyone who asks for a person. Every time, with no attempt to keep them talking to the AI.
  7. Anything it is not sure about. The safe default is to take a message and say when someone will call back.

For law firms there is one more check. The receptionist collects names for a conflict check, but the check and the decision to take the client stay with the firm. Our guide on law firm automation covers the rest of intake.

What 100 calls a month would cost

Pricing models differ, so the cheapest headline price is not always the cheapest bill. Here is one example at list price, monthly billing, for a firm with 100 calls a month that last about 3 minutes each, so about 300 minutes.

ProductMonthly costHow we got there
Smith.ai$212.50Pro, 75 calls plus 25 extra calls at $2.50
Ruby$1,725500-minute plan. The 200-minute plan is $720, and its overage rate is not shown on the pricing page
Goodcall$79Starter, if those 100 calls come from 100 or fewer different callers
Rosie$149Scale, 1,000 minutes, and it includes transfers
Dialzara$135Business Pro, 220 minutes plus 80 extra minutes at $0.45
My AI Front Deskabout $114$99 for 200 minutes. Each extra minute uses 25 credits. The plan includes 1,000 overage credits, about 40 minutes, and more credits cost $10 per 1,000

Count your own calls and minutes for one month first. Your phone provider's bill or call log usually shows both.

Our verdict on each

  • Smith.ai

    The safest first choice for a law firm. It lists a native Clio integration, has a free plan to test on real calls, and can pass a hard call to a live receptionist. Per-call pricing adds up if you get many short calls.

  • Ruby

    For firms that want a trained person on every call and are happy to pay for it. It is the most expensive option here per minute, so it suits firms where each new client is worth a lot and calls are few.

  • Goodcall

    The most predictable bill if the same people call you again and again, because it counts callers, not minutes. It names fewer integrations than Smith.ai, so check how messages reach your case or client system.

  • Rosie

    A cheap way to find out whether AI answering works for your callers. For a firm we would start on Scale, because the $49 plan does not list transfers to a person.

  • Dialzara

    The lowest entry price, and it lists blind transfers to your team on every plan. 60 minutes a month is little for a busy office, so price the plan you will actually use.

  • My AI Front Desk

    Bundles phone answering with web chat, text messages and a simple CRM. Good if you want one tool for all of it. More to set up and more to keep an eye on.

How to start without risk

  1. Start with evenings and weekends only. Keep daytime calls with your team for the first month.
  2. Give it a short script. Who you help, what you do not do, how to book, and the hand-off list above.
  3. Make ten test calls yourself, including an angry caller and someone asking for advice.
  4. Read every call summary for the first two weeks, then fix the script.
  5. Tell callers they are speaking with an automated assistant and offer a person.

Setup time. The vendors say minutes. Dialzara says most businesses are live in about 15 minutes, and My AI Front Desk says setup takes 5 minutes. Our estimate is one day to write the script and one to two weeks of checking calls before you rely on it.

More tools for small firms, sorted by task, are in our tools catalogue, and the ones for law firms are on AI tools for small law firms.


Andrew Baevich

Andrew Baevich runs a small team at baevich.com that sets up AI automations for law and accounting firms. He founded and ran CyberFox, and has spent more than ten years building and running service businesses.

Written with AI assistance and fact-checked before publishing. Prices and plans come from each vendor's public pricing page and docs, checked on 20 November 2026. We have not tested every product listed here, and vendors change prices often, so confirm on the vendor site before you buy.